1X
Herman Aizawa, Superintendent of Hawaii's Department of Education, and Karen Knudsen, a member of the State Board of Education, join Roth to take stock of Hawaii's public schools. Aizawa frames his administration around literacy, describing his Success Compact initiative and a three-legged accountability model—school indicators, classroom measures, and comparative standardized scores—arguing that the media fixates on that final leg alone. Knudsen supports an elected board and cites evidence that appointed boards produce no better student outcomes. Both agree the principal is the pivotal figure, and Aizawa contends that student literacy gains will naturally reduce discipline problems. Callers challenge both guests directly: a Maui school counselor argues the state's high-school exit test is culturally and economically biased and should be replaced by achievement-based records; a Big Island teacher cites class sizes of 30 or more as the key barrier to effective teaching; and another caller contends that American-style critical thinking, not test-score memorization, is what employers need from graduates. The episode's sharpest exchange concerns whether self-esteem programs lower the academic bar or whether, as Aizawa insists, genuine student success is the only path to self-esteem.
Transcript
Read or download the full transcript (.txt). Speaker labels were assigned automatically and may contain errors.