1X
James Scott, President of Punahou School, argued that the principles long taken for granted in Hawaiian private education — parental choice and school-level decentralization — offer the surest path to improving the state's public schools. Scott contended that public school reform efforts of the previous decade ultimately reduce to those two strategies, and proposed charter schools as a concrete mechanism: publicly funded, tuition-free, and non-selective, but exempt from most state regulations and governed by performance agreements with specified outcomes. He acknowledged that charter schools might divert public dollars from existing schools and create uncertainty for teachers. Callers raised related anxieties — that private schools draw the strongest pupils from the public system, that safety rather than curriculum drives many enrollment decisions, and that public school teachers choosing private schools for their own children signals a deeper problem. Scott argued that private institutions like Punahou have a social responsibility to help improve public education and that collaboration between the two sectors should increase. The standing question is whether introducing charter school governance — greater autonomy in exchange for direct accountability — can raise the quality of public education in Hawaii without additional public funding.
Transcript
Read or download the full transcript (.txt). Speaker labels were assigned automatically and may contain errors.
Companion newspaper commentaries
Commentaries by the guests, published in The Honolulu Advertiser around the broadcast.
